02 Disciplinary Proceedings

High Council of Justice

Plenary review of appeals by judges and complainants against disciplinary chamber decisions, review of dismissal recommendations, establishing unified disciplinary practice and final HCJ decisions.

Appeals against chamber decisions on my report

Below is the infographic and register of appeals against disciplinary chamber decisions reviewed by the HCJ plenary on my report or at my proposal

Chamber appeals reviewed 12
  • 3 proceedings closed
  • 2 warning
  • 1 severe reprimand
  • 3 submission for suspension
  • 3 submission for dismissal
Chamber decisions upheld appeal dismissed, the chamber sanction left in force
3 / 12
Set aside or modified chamber decision set aside in full or in part, or modified
9 / 12
At my proposal decision adopted at my proposal, another HCJ member was rapporteur
2
Date Judge and court Sanction
Halonkin Serhii Anatoliiovych Poltavskyi Court of Appeal Third Disciplinary Chamber, 31.01.2024, No. 283/3дп/15-24 — severe reprimand Chamber rapporteur: Sasevych O.M. Proposal authored by Maselko R.A. Submission for dismissal modified Grand Chamber: HCJ decision upheld
Slobodin Mykhailo Mykolaiovych Eastern Commercial Court of Appeal Third Disciplinary Chamber, 09.12.2020, No. 3439/3дп/15-20 — warning Chamber rapporteur: Matviichuk V.V. HCJ rapporteur: Maselko R.A. Earlier HCJ decision: 04.02.2021 No. 242/0/15-21 (set aside by the Grand Chamber on 17.02.2022, case No. 11-97сап21) Proceedings closed set aside
Hnyp Oleksandr Ivanovych Semenivskyi District Court of Chernihiv Oblast Third Disciplinary Chamber, 01.05.2024, No. 1341/3дп/15-24 — reprimand HCJ rapporteur: Maselko R.A. Submission for temporary suspension from the administration of justice for three months modified Grand Chamber: HCJ decision set aside
Arestova Liudmyla Valeriivna Donetskyi Circuit Administrative Court Third Disciplinary Chamber, 07.08.2024, No. 2397/3дп/15-24 — submission for dismissal Chamber rapporteur: Sasevych O.M. HCJ rapporteur: Maselko R.A. Submission for dismissal upheld Grand Chamber: HCJ decision upheld
An Olha Viktorivna Vinnytskyi City Court of Vinnytsia Oblast Third Disciplinary Chamber, 11.09.2024, No. 2646/3дп/15-24 — warning Chamber rapporteur: Sasevych O.M. HCJ rapporteur: Maselko R.A. Warning upheld
Shalota Kostiantyn Valeriiovych Korolovskyi District Court of Zhytomyr First Disciplinary Chamber, 18.09.2020, No. 2658/1дп/15-20 — reprimand Chamber rapporteur: Krasnoshchokova N.S. HCJ rapporteur: Maselko R.A. Earlier HCJ decision: 02.02.2021 No. 195/0/15-21 (set aside by the Grand Chamber on 23.09.2021, case No. 11-90сап21) Proceedings closed set aside
Yaselskyi Anatolii Mykhailovych Sviatoshynskyi District Court of Kyiv Third Disciplinary Chamber, 08.10.2025, No. 2083/3дп/15-25 — reprimand Chamber rapporteur: Kandziuba O.V. Proposal authored by Maselko R.A. Submission for temporary suspension from the administration of justice for two months set aside in part Grand Chamber: HCJ decision upheld
Runov Volodymyr Yuriiovych Sumskyi Court of Appeal Third Disciplinary Chamber, 21.07.2021, No. 1645/3дп/15-21 — reprimand Chamber rapporteur: Shvetsova L.A. HCJ rapporteur: Maselko R.A. Earlier HCJ decisions: 30.11.2023 No. 1159/0/15-23 (set aside by the Grand Chamber on 11.04.2024, case No. 990SCGC/6/23) and 24.09.2024 No. 2795/0/15-24 Proceedings closed set aside
Kovtun Nataliia Hryhorivna Saksahanskyi District Court of Kryvyi Rih, Dnipropetrovsk Oblast First Disciplinary Chamber, 17.06.2024, No. 1838/1дп/15-24 — warning Chamber rapporteur: Kotelevets A.V. HCJ rapporteur: Maselko R.A. Warning upheld
Polishchuk Andrii Serhiiovych Myronivskyi District Court of Kyiv Oblast Third Disciplinary Chamber, 15.10.2025, No. 2119/3дп/15-25 — submission for dismissal Chamber rapporteur: Sasevych O.M. HCJ rapporteur: Maselko R.A. Submission for dismissal set aside in part
Hrechko Yurii Valeriiovych Synelnykivskyi City District Court of Dnipropetrovsk Oblast Third Disciplinary Chamber, 16.06.2021, No. 1373/3дп/15-21 — submission for dismissal Chamber rapporteur: Hrechkivskyi P.M. HCJ rapporteur: Maselko R.A. Earlier HCJ decisions: 14.12.2023 No. 1321/0/15-23 (set aside by the Grand Chamber on 13.06.2024, case No. 990SCGC/2/24) and 07.11.2024 No. 3260/0/15-24 Severe reprimand set aside in part
Zdorovytsia Olena Volodymyrivna Dobropilskyi City District Court of Donetsk Oblast First Disciplinary Chamber, 08.07.2024, No. 2060/1дп/15-24 — submission for dismissal Chamber rapporteur: Kvasha O.O. HCJ rapporteur: Maselko R.A. Earlier HCJ decision: 31.10.2024 No. 3193/0/15-24 (set aside by the Grand Chamber on 17.04.2025, case No. 990SCGC/27/24) Submission for temporary suspension from the administration of justice for three months set aside in part
Avatar