Appeals and review of decisions of the Second Disciplinary Chamber and the plenary High Council of Justice before the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court: analysis of decision stability, Supreme Court legal stances, and judicial disciplinary standards.
Appeals before the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court
Below is the infographic and register of disciplinary decisions involving my participation and reports reviewed by the Supreme Court
Reviewed by Grand Chamber of SC 13
5warning
2severe reprimand
2submission for suspension
4submission for dismissal
Upheld by Grand ChamberGrand Chamber confirmed the HCJ decision
9 / 13
Set aside by CourtHCJ decision set aside or modified by court
Yaselskyi Anatolii MykhailovychSviatoshynskyi District Court of Kyiv Third Disciplinary Chamber, 08.10.2025, No. 2083/3дп/15-25 — reprimand Chamber rapporteur: Kandziuba O.V. Proposal authored by Maselko R.A. Grand Chamber ruling of 05.05.2026, case No. 990SCGC/26/25
Submission for temporary suspension from the administration of justice for two months Grand Chamber: upheld
Hnyp Oleksandr IvanovychSemenivskyi District Court of Chernihiv Oblast Third Disciplinary Chamber, 01.05.2024, No. 1341/3дп/15-24 — reprimand HCJ rapporteur: Maselko R.A. Grand Chamber ruling of 23.01.2025, case No. 990SCGC/19/24 Separate opinions of HCJ members: Burlakov S.Yu., Usyk H.I.
Submission for temporary suspension from the administration of justice for three months Grand Chamber: set aside
Zdorovytsia Olena VolodymyrivnaDobropilskyi City District Court of Donetsk Oblast First Disciplinary Chamber, 08.07.2024, No. 2060/1дп/15-24 — submission for dismissal Chamber rapporteur: Kvasha O.O. HCJ rapporteur: Maselko R.A. Earlier HCJ decision: 31.10.2024 No. 3193/0/15-24 (set aside by Grand Chamber on 17.04.2025, case No. 990SCGC/27/24)
Submission for dismissal Grand Chamber: set aside
Halonkin Serhii AnatoliiovychPoltavskyi Court of Appeal Third Disciplinary Chamber, 31.01.2024, No. 283/3дп/15-24 — severe reprimand Chamber rapporteur: Sasevych O.M. Proposal authored by Maselko R.A. Grand Chamber ruling of 12.12.2024, case No. 990SCGC/16/24
Severe reprimand Grand Chamber: upheld
Makharynets Dmytro YevheniiovychRivnenskyi Circuit Administrative Court HCJ decision of 10.02.2026 No. 179/0/15-26 — upheld Separate opinion of HCJ member: Burlakov S.Yu.
Submission for dismissal Grand Chamber: upheld
Shyshkin Oleksii VolodymyrovychShevchenkivskyi District Court of Kharkiv HCJ decision of 16.09.2025 No. 1951/0/15-25 — upheld
Severe reprimand Grand Chamber: upheld
Burkhan Serhii MykhailovychVerkhnodniprovskyi District Court of Dnipropetrovsk Oblast HCJ decision of 03.06.2025 No. 1192/0/15-25 — upheld
Submission for dismissal Grand Chamber: upheld
Mykytenko Vitalii MykhailovychOktiabrskyi District Court of Poltava HCJ decision of 27.05.2025 No. 1119/0/15-25 — upheld
Warning Grand Chamber: upheld
Bysaha Taras YuriiovychZakarpatskyi Court of Appeal HCJ decision of 23.01.2025 No. 113/0/15-25 — upheld Grand Chamber ruling of 15.05.2025, case No. 990SCGC/6/25
Warning Grand Chamber: upheld
Bratkiv Iryna IhorivnaBilhorod-Dnistrovskyi District Court of Odesa Oblast HCJ decision of 08.10.2024 No. 2942/0/15-24 — upheld Grand Chamber ruling of 20.02.2025, case No. 990SCGC/25/24
Warning Grand Chamber: upheld
Prytula Nataliia HryhorivnaShevchenkivskyi District Court of Kyiv HCJ decision of 30.01.2025 No. 149/0/15-25 (set aside by Grand Chamber on 21.07.2025, case No. 990SCGC/7/25) HCJ decision of 23.12.2025 No. 2800/0/15-25 — 2DC decision set aside, proceedings closed
Warning Grand Chamber: set aside
Vovk Serhii VolodymyrovychPecherskyi District Court of Kyiv HCJ decision of 25.06.2024 No. 1949/0/15-24 (set aside by Grand Chamber on 30.01.2025, case No. 990SCGC/17/24) HCJ decision of 14.10.2025 No. 2115/0/15-25 — 2DC decision set aside, proceedings closed Separate opinions of Grand Chamber judges: Hrytsiv M.I., Pilkov K.M., Usenko Ye.A.