01 Building the judiciary

Candidates for whom I was rapporteur

Complete register of reviews of recommendations by the High Qualification Commission of Judges of Ukraine regarding appointments of judicial candidates to first instance and appellate courts, as well as qualification assessments, where Roman Maselko was rapporteur.

Appointment review metrics

Decisions where I was rapporteur — summarized results of appointment recommendation reviews

Recommendations reviewed 65
  • 56 appoint
  • 8 refuse
  • 1 no final decision
first instance
38 candidates 4 refusals
10.5% refusals
appellate
21 candidates 3 refusals
14.3% refusals
qualification assessment
6 candidates 1 refusals
16.7% refusals
Candidate and court Procedure Conclusion Voting result
Vikhrov Oleksandr Volodymyrovych Commercial Court of Zaporizhzhia Oblast first instance refuse refuse: 11/15
Savchuk Iryna Oleksandrivna Zhytomyrskyi District Court of Zhytomyr Oblast first instance refuse refuse: 8/14
Shevchuk Ruslana Mykolaivna Zastavnivskyi District Court of Chernivtsi Oblast first instance appoint appoint
Yakimets Taras Ihorovych Ternopilskyi City District Court first instance appoint appoint
Anapriiuk Snizhana Petrivna Fastivskyi City District Court of Kyiv Oblast first instance appoint appoint
Kuzmina Bohdana Mykolaivna Commercial Court of Kirovohrad Oblast first instance appoint appoint
Hladka Olena Valentynivna Leninskyi District Court of Kharkiv first instance appoint appoint
Smyk Maryna Mykolaivna Rokytnianskyi District Court of Kyiv Oblast first instance appoint appoint
Fedko Oleksandra Anatoliivna Commercial Court of Zaporizhzhia Oblast first instance appoint appoint
Diachenko Oleksii Mykolaiovych Kyivskyi District Court of Kharkiv first instance appoint appoint
Yuzkiv Mykola Ivanovych Ternopilskyi Circuit Administrative Court first instance appoint appoint
Ivasenko Solomiia Mykhailivna Starosambirskyi District Court of Lviv Oblast first instance appoint appoint
Sidorova Iryna Anatoliivna Lvivskyi Circuit Administrative Court first instance appoint appoint
Hurzhii Anna Vasylivna Shyriaivskyi District Court of Odesa Oblast first instance appoint appoint
Shynkarenko Alina Ivanivna Oleksandrivskyi District Court of Donetsk Oblast qualification assessment appoint appoint
Chornyi Ihor Yaroslavovych Zhovtnevyi District Court of Kryvyi Rih qualification assessment appoint appoint
Zhuk Hanna Volodymyrivna Sambirskyi City District Court of Lviv Oblast first instance refuse refuse: unanimous
Petrenko Oleksandr Volodymyrovych Prydniprovskyi District Court of Cherkasy first instance appoint appoint
Krasnoborov Oleksandr Valeriiovych Podilskyi District Court of Kyiv first instance appoint appoint
Kovalenko Nataliia Viktorivna Lysychanskyi City Court of Luhansk Oblast qualification assessment appoint appoint
Martyniuk Vasyl Ivanovych Sniatynskyi District Court of Ivano-Frankivsk Oblast first instance appoint appoint
Patsko Olha Oleksiivna Korostenskyi City District Court of Zhytomyr Oblast first instance appoint appoint
Tkachuk Olena Valeriivna Poltavskyi District Court of Poltava Oblast first instance appoint appoint
Syrko Yosyp Yosypovych Kaluskyi City District Court of Ivano-Frankivsk Oblast first instance appoint appoint
Startanovych Dmytro Volodymyrovych Tsentralno-Miskyi District Court of Kryvyi Rih first instance appoint appoint
Lastovychak Viktor Yuriiovych Rakhivskyi District Court of Zakarpattia Oblast first instance appoint appoint
Bessonov Oleksandr Volodymyrovych Teplodarskyi City Court of Odesa Oblast first instance refuse refuse
Kovaliuk Oksana Mykolaivna Yaremchanskyi City Court of Ivano-Frankivsk Oblast first instance appoint appoint
Lebed Oleksandr Volodymyrovych Trostianetskyi District Court of Sumy Oblast first instance appoint appoint
Mykhaliuk Olha Vasylivna Liubashivskyi District Court of Odesa Oblast first instance appoint appoint
Pidhirska Halyna Olehivna Kirovohradskyi District Court of Kirovohrad Oblast first instance appoint appoint
Ponomar Vitalii Oleksiiovych Sosnivskyi District Court of Cherkasy first instance appoint appoint
Somok Olena Anatoliivna Bilotserkivskyi City District Court of Kyiv Oblast first instance appoint appoint
Balatska Olha Romanivna Rivnenskyi City Court of Rivne Oblast first instance appoint appoint
Pysarev Oleksandr Yuriiovych Stryiskyi City District Court of Lviv Oblast first instance appoint appoint
Kravchenko Tetiana Mykolaivna Zvenyhorodskyi District Court of Cherkasy Oblast first instance appoint appoint
Karetnyk Yuliia Mykolaivna Polohivskyi District Court of Zaporizhzhia Oblast first instance appoint appoint
Korol Oleksandr Valentynovych Iziaslavskyi District Court of Khmelnytskyi Oblast first instance appoint appoint
Buchynskyi Andrii Bohdanovych Verkhovynskyi District Court of Ivano-Frankivsk Oblast first instance appoint appoint
Peten Yana Leonidivna Nedryhailivskyi District Court of Sumy Oblast qualification assessment — left without consideration
Nevmerzhytska Olena Andriivna Korostenskyi City District Court of Zhytomyr Oblast first instance appoint appoint
Andreichuk Liubomyr Viktorovych Central Commercial Court of Appeal appellate appoint appoint
Lavreniuk Tetiana Anatoliivna Eastern Commercial Court of Appeal appellate appoint appoint
Pyvovar Iryna Viktorivna First Administrative Court of Appeal appellate appoint appoint
Kataieva Ella Valeriivna Fifth Administrative Court of Appeal appellate refuse appoint
Sukhovarov Artem Volodymyrovych Central Commercial Court of Appeal appellate appoint appoint
Nikolenko Mykhailo Oleksandrovych Central Commercial Court of Appeal appellate refuse appoint
Pavlenko Nataliia Anatoliivna Southwestern Commercial Court of Appeal appellate appoint appoint
Valiukh Viktor Mykolaiovych Eighth Administrative Court of Appeal appellate appoint appoint
Yasynovskyi Ivan Hryhorovych Sixth Administrative Court of Appeal appellate appoint appoint
Kosolap Maryna Mykolaivna Sumskyi Court of Appeal appellate appoint appoint
Kuznetsov Dmytro Volodymyrovych Zhytomyrskyi Court of Appeal appellate appoint appoint
Chebotarenko Oksana Leonidivna Zhytomyrskyi Court of Appeal appellate appoint appoint
Pankeieva Viktoriia Anatoliivna Zhytomyrskyi Court of Appeal appellate appoint appoint
Bielousov Artur Yevhenovych Zhytomyrskyi Court of Appeal appellate refuse appoint
Zamchenko Anna Oleksandrivna Sumskyi Court of Appeal appellate appoint appoint
Shynkarenko Alina Ivanivna Sumskyi Court of Appeal appellate appoint appoint
Bondar Volodymyr Borysovych Sumskyi Court of Appeal appellate appoint appoint
Yanhol Yevhenii Vasylovych Sumskyi Court of Appeal appellate appoint appoint
Remezok Anastasiia Yuriivna Oleksandriiskyi City District Court of Kirovohrad Oblast first instance appoint appoint
Solodovnikov Roman Serhiiovych Zaporizkyi Court of Appeal appellate appoint appoint
Maksymiv Ihor Volodymyrovych Rozhniativskyi District Court of Ivano-Frankivsk Oblast qualification assessment appoint appoint
Novytskyi Yevhen Anatoliiovych Baranivskyi District Court of Zhytomyr Oblast qualification assessment refuse
Tokariev Artem Hennadiiovych Mykolaivskyi Court of Appeal appellate appoint appoint
Fortuna Tetiana Yuriivna Mykolaivskyi Court of Appeal appellate appoint appoint
Avatar